View More

Achieving High MLSS and Low Sludge Volume in Sequencing Batch Reactors (SBRs)

The Sequencing Batch Reactor (SBR) is a variation of the activated sludge process that operates in a fill-and-draw mode, performing equalization, biological treatment (aeration), and clarification in a single tank, but in a time-sequenced manner. This inherent operational flexibility allows SBRs to create highly specific conditions that promote the growth of dense, well-settling biomass, thereby enabling high MLSS concentrations without the typical problems of sludge bulking or excessive sludge volume. This advantage is further amplified by the development of Aerobic Granular Sludge (AGS) technology within SBRs.

I. Scenarios and Operational Principles in SBRs Favouring High MLSS and Low Sludge Volume:

SBRs achieve this optimal state through their unique operational cycle, which essentially "selects" for well-settling biomass:

1. Batch Operation and Hydraulic Selection:

Fill Phase: Wastewater enters the reactor, mixing with the existing biomass.

React (Aeration) Phase: Aeration and mixing occur, facilitating biological treatment.

Settle Phase (Quiescent Settling): Aeration and mixing cease. This is the crucial phase. Unlike continuous flow systems with external clarifiers, the SBR relies on in-situ settling. Only sludge that settles rapidly and compactly will form a distinct, dense layer at the bottom.

Decant Phase: The treated supernatant is drawn off from the top.

Idle/Waste Sludge Phase: (Optional) Excess sludge is wasted from the bottom, and a small amount of sludge may remain for the next cycle.

The Selection Mechanism: Due to the fixed, relatively short settling time, any sludge floc that settles slowly or remains dispersed will not settle completely within the allocated time. This poorly settling biomass will likely be drawn off with the decanted effluent. Over successive cycles, this creates a strong hydraulic selection pressure favoring the growth and retention of dense, fast-settling flocs. This naturally leads to low SVI values, even with high MLSS.

2. Varied Environmental Conditions within a Cycle (Feast/Famine, Anoxic/Aerobic):

Feast-Famine Regime: During the fill phase, the incoming wastewater provides a "feast" of food. As the cycle progresses and organic matter is consumed, the biomass enters a "famine" state. This feast/famine cycle has been shown to favor floc-forming bacteria over many filamentous types, leading to better settleability.

Alternating Redox Conditions: Many SBRs are designed with intermittent aeration to achieve biological nutrient removal (BNR). This creates alternating aerobic, anoxic, and even anaerobic conditions within a single tank. These fluctuating redox states can also influence microbial populations, often favoring those that form denser flocs and can rapidly switch metabolic pathways, contributing to good settling and the ability to operate at high MLSS.

3. High Sludge Retention Time (SRT) and Solids Concentration:

The SBR's batch nature allows for independent control of hydraulic retention time (HRT) and SRT. Operators can maintain a long SRT (old sludge age) by controlling the wasting rate.

A longer SRT promotes the growth of slower-growing organisms, including nitrifiers and certain floc-formers, and can lead to a more stable, mature biomass capable of handling shock loads

The efficient capture and retention of settled solids within the same reactor allows SBRs to maintain high MLSS concentrations (often 4,000-8,000 mg/L or even higher) without needing a separate clarifier and return sludge pumping system, which are prone to upsets in conventional systems.

4. Absence of External Clarifier Issues:

In conventional activated sludge plants, poor clarifier design, hydraulic overloads, short-circuiting, or denitrification in the clarifier can all lead to solids washout, even if the sludge health (SVI) is good.

SBRs eliminate the external clarifier, meaning there are no associated problems with return activated sludge (RAS) pumping rates, sludge blanket management, or denitrification in the clarifier that could compromise sludge retention and overall MLSS.

II. Aerobic Granular Sludge (AGS) Contribution to High MLSS and Low Sludge Volume:

Aerobic Granular Sludge (AGS) technology is a revolutionary development that capitalizes on and significantly enhances the inherent advantages of the SBR system. AGS systems like Nereda® are prime examples of achieving extremely high MLSS concentrations (often 8,000-15,000 mg/L or more) with exceptionally low sludge volumes (SVI values as low as 20-50 mL/g).

How AGS contributes:

1. Unique Granular Structure:

Instead of irregular flocs, the biomass self-immobilizes into dense, compact, spherical or elliptical granules (0.2-5 mm in diameter). These granules are inherently much denser and settle much faster than conventional activated sludge flocs.

The layered structure of granules allows for different microbial communities to thrive in anoxic/anaerobic zones within the granule while the outer layer is aerobic, facilitating simultaneous nitrification, denitrification, and phosphorus removal in a single step.

2. Enhanced Hydraulic Selection:

AGS systems in SBRs typically employ very short and intense settling phases (e.g., 5-10 minutes) and high decant rates. This imposes an even more stringent hydraulic selection pressure than conventional SBRs.

Only the very fastest-settling granules are retained in the reactor, while any slower-settling flocs or disintegrated granules are washed out with the effluent. This "weeding out" process continuously refines the granular population.

3. High Biomass Concentration and Activity:

Due to their high density and excellent settling properties, AGS systems can maintain significantly higher MLSS concentrations (often double or triple that of conventional activated sludge) in the reactor.

This high biomass concentration, combined with the efficient mass transfer within the granules, leads to high volumetric loading rates and superior treatment performance (e.g., robust COD, BOD, nitrogen, and phosphorus removal).

4. Superior Settling Velocity:

Aerobic granules have settling velocities that are typically 3 to 10 times higher than those of conventional activated sludge flocs.


This allows for:

  • Rapid and complete phase separation in the SBR.

  • Minimization of the "sludge volume" (low SVI) as the granules quickly form a compact bed at the bottom of the reactor.

  • Reduced footprint requirements for the treatment plant, as smaller reactors can handle higher loads.

5. Robustness and Stability:

The compact granular structure makes AGS more resistant to hydraulic shocks, toxic loads, and shear forces compared to fragile flocs.

The dense nature of the granules prevents them from being easily washed out of the system, contributing to more stable operation at high biomass concentrations.

Conclusion:

Sequencing Batch Reactors are inherently well-suited for achieving high MLSS concentrations and low sludge volumes due to their batch operation and the hydraulic selection pressures they impose during the settling and decant phases. This design allows for independent control of sludge age and promotes the growth of well-settling biomass.

The advent of Aerobic Granular Sludge (AGS) technology has revolutionized this capability. By fostering the formation of dense, rapidly settling granules within the SBR environment, AGS systems enable operators to achieve unprecedented MLSS levels with remarkably low SVI values. This combination results in highly compact, energy-efficient, and robust wastewater treatment plants capable of achieving excellent effluent quality while minimizing the physical footprint and operational challenges often associated with conventional activated sludge systems.